It seems some of my esteemed colleagues decided to have a “Blogging” contest. They have, therefore, pressured me in to posting a couple of blog entries. I *hates* them so.

I’m a regular at the Indianapolis Code and Coffee. If you’re local, join us at 7:00 am on Thursday! Korff and I started doing some Project Euler problems in Haskell this week. Matt Swanson made a comment about Euler being way focused on math and wanting Project Euler for “practical” things. His idea of practical was, as an example, displaying a list of items on a web page. Hrm… Reminds me of Ruby Koans or Rails for Zombies. I’ll get to that post in a few days.

I’ve done some of the Euler problems and they are *really* math oriented. The point of these exercises really is to think about math and the relationship of numbers. What a programmer can take from these exercises is focusing on algorithmic implementation and optimization. It is not that we solve it, but that we tweak and re tweak our implementation to be faster or more expressive. It is a great way to learn about a programming language in the small.

Koans are small guided steps. Where Project Euler expects a single number as an answer with out regard to HOW you got the answer, koans are all about the journey. They are usually language specific. They are a series of automated test failures that allow a conversation of learning similar to *The Little Schemer*. Again, koans are about learning small concepts a little at a time.

Katas are also about the journey. The problems that katas use are actually incidental. It isn’t important that I’m dealing with an incomplete simulation of a bowling game, or pricing some children’s books. It is about the things you do around the problem. Katas are about the red/green/refactor cycle.

All of these have their place and appeal to different people for different reasons. But they deal with software in the small. Like writing short stories, they teach you how to communicate more effectively. These lessons can be taken to larger structures, but they can also teach a kind of tunnel vision. A short story is not a novel and their structures are different. With that caveat out of the way, enjoy yourself. If you’re pressed for time, they can be great bite-sized puzzlers and exercises. They can also teach you to take care with the smallest parts of your code.